Why Test Soil Biology

Diverse soil biology is crucial for healthy plant growth, healthy soil and healthy environment.

Those tiny creatures in soil are essential in transforming organic and inorganic compounds into plant nutrients and humus. Most of them form mutually beneficial associations with plants and protect plants from pathogenic microorganisms and pests. Beneficial microorganisms also increase soil infiltration, water and nutrients holding capacity and prevent soil erosion by forming stable soil aggregates. In other words, they perform all kinds of ecological functions and some of them we have yet to discover!

Benefits of Testing Soil Biology

Starting when she was at Colorado State University and continuing later, Dr. Elaine Ingham and the team of other researches were looking at and comparing soil biology of different ecosystems. They analysed highly productive natural ecosystems (short- and tallgrass prairies, mountain meadows, deciduous forests, wetlands, alpine, tundra, conifer forests etc) as well as productive and not so productive cultivated ecosystems (row crops, pastures, orchards, vineyards, vegetables, dairy production etc) across different climates. One of the main discoveries made at this time was that in any climate different sets of organisms in soil set the stage for different plants to grow. In other words, types and amounts of soil microbes, especially the ratio between bacteria and fungi, define the stage of plant succession, i.e. the types of plants that will thrive in this soil at this stage of microbial succession. Optimal ranges for bacterial & fungal biomass as well as for protozoa & nematodes numbers were determined for each stage of plant succession. For example, it was discovered that weeds thrive when F:B ratio is around 0.1 & predators are barely present, and cannot survive when biology shifts towards higher fungal biomass and developed protozoa & nematodes communities giving space later successional plants. They also researched how different soil management practices affect soil microorganisms and how to restore soil biology in degraded soils.

Considering the above, the benefits of testing soil biology are: 

1) Soil Biology Assessment shows if biology in your soil/compost beneficial and enough for the plant you want to grow.

2) Soil biology assessments help you evaluate the effectiveness of your practices or find the root cause of poor plant growth, plant diseases, weed/pest pressure and make adjustments accordingly.

Soil Biology Assessment will show this information about your soil/compost:

  • which organism groups are missing or imbalanced
  • estimated levels and diversity of beneficial and plant-pathogenic microbes
  • if the ratio between bacteria and fungi is right for the plants you want to grow
  • if there are potentially pathogenic to human types of bacteria present
  • which conditions are prevalent – aerobic or anaerobic

And so much more!

The technique that we use to identify and estimate levels of different organism groups is described here. Overall,  biological soil analysis is a snapshot of a current condition of the Soil Food Web community in your soil. This information will help you restore bacteria, fungi and predators in your soil to optimal levels for your plants while improving soil health.

All data is compiled in a report with table charts, microscope images and detailed interpretation of the results so that you could make sense of your numbers and fix the problem.

Interpretation of the Results

Below are examples of how you can identify the root cause of a problem based on the soil biology test results.

Bacteria make enzymes to decompose and pull nutrients from organic matter & sands, silts and clays. Aerobic bacteria release about 80% carbon as CO2 while decomposing materials and retain all other nutrients (e.g. N, P, S, K) in their bodies preventing them from leaching and volatilizing. They also glue mineral particles and organic matter together into micro-aggregates thus creating smallest blocks of soil structure. Anaerobic bacteria, on the other hand, release about 50% of carbon as CO2, but also release methane (CH4) and other important plant nutrients as gases (e.g. N as NH3, S as H2S, P as PH3) basically blowing off soil fertility into the atmosphere. These bacteria also produce strong organic acids and ethanol that harm plants and some of them are plant or human pathogens. Some facultative anaerobes like actinobacteria or nitrogen-fixing bacteria perform important functions in soil when in normal ranges. So we want diverse mostly aerobic bacteria to extract and retain a diverse set of nutrients and start building structure to prevent anaerobic conditions.

  • Low/no bacterial biomass. Bacteria are usually present in any soil unless there was some serious contamination or disturbance. Low bacterial biomass can be, again, a result of some kind of disturbance (e.g. a drought), contaminants (e.g. herbicides, pesticides, salts, heavy metals) or low soil organic matter, low/no vegetation.
  • High bacterial biomass is not a problem if there are enough fungi and microorganisms from other trophic levels for the plant’s stage of succession* (read about F:B ratio below). High imbalanced bacterial levels are typical for tilled soils (fluffed layer). Tillage slices, dices and crushes all organisms larger than bacteria, and destroys soil macro-aggregates built by fungi as well as passageways and structures built by protozoa, nematodes and larger critters. Bacteria then bloom due to increased oxygen levels, limited competition, and greater access to previously unavailable surfaces of organic matter. In this scenario the soil no longer can grow plants without external inputs like fertilizers that only aggravate the problem with biology further. Composts that have been turned and mixed too much / made with too much nitrogen materials are also mostly bacterial dominated.
  • Anaerobic bacteria are common for compacted soils, waterlogged or where an excessive amount of nitrogen or manure has been applied. The main causes of compaction are leaving soil bare (compaction from the rainfall), tillage (compaction layers below fluffy layers where a plow share presses down the soil), heavy equipment and lack of beneficial biology for some reason (e.g. contamination, disturbance) which leads to lack of structure. In water, the oxygen diffusion rate is very low, that’s why waterlogged soils are anaerobic. Excessive high nitrogen materials promote growth of anaerobic bacteria because initially aerobic bacteria start growing rapidly on those food sources and use up oxygen faster than it diffuses into soil/compost so that anaerobic conditions occur.

Fungi, Yeasts and Oomycetes. Fungi that are beneficial for plants are mostly aerobic. Along with bacteria, fungi decompose organic matter and can obtain nutrients from the mineral soil particles. However, while bacteria prefer simple foods, fungi are able to decompose hard-to-digest organic materials like lignins in woody plants. Fungi are also good in storing carbon in their cell walls and things like calcium oxalate crystals on the surfaces of their hyphae which helps in balancing Ca:Mg ratio and floculation of clay. Like bacteria, fungi produce glues and don’t get washed away retaining nutrients in soil. Another important function of fungal hyphae is physically binding micro-aggregates and soil particles into stable macro-aggregates that are necessary for a good soil structure. Well-structured soil has high water infiltration and water holding capacity and is full of oxygen which prevents anaerobic pathogenic organisms from growing. Some fungi can also protect plants from pathogens directly such as nematode-trapping fungi that parasitize disease-causing nematodes and fungi that feed on insects. Among fungi there is a type of mutualistic fungi called Mycorrhizal fungi. In exchange for carbon, mycorrhizal fungi solubilize phosphorus and deliver nutrients and water from far away directly to the plant. Yeasts are single-celled anaerobic fungi that preferentially metabolize sugars converting them into alcohol (harmful for roots) and CO2. They also produce strong organic acids such as succinic acid, acetic acid that can help reduce pathogens, but in large amounts make soil too acidic. Some beneficial filamentous fungi have a yeast phase to survive anaerobic conditions. Pathogenic fungi and Oomycetes (that resemble fungi morphologically but are not fungi phylogenetically) are mostly anaerobic. 60-70% of Oomycetes species can cause decreased production or plant death if conditions are right. So we want to see diverse, mostly aerobic fungi to provide all the benefits for plants and soil. Beneficial fungi should be more than double the oomycetes’ and disease-causing fungi’ biomass to out-compete them and hold in check.

  • Low/no fungal biomass is common for agricultural soils where tillage and fungicides as well as any other -icides have been used. Other disturbances (e.g. flooding) and contaminants kill fungi and other beneficial microbes as well. For instance, high concentrations of salts are detrimental for soil life including fungi. Examples of salts: synthetic fertilizers, lime, gypsum (salt and a fungicide!), salty manure, salts in irrigation water. Basically, the same factors are harmful to bacteria, fungi and the rest of the Soil Food Web except for tillage that promotes bacterial growth.
  • High fungal biomass is not a problem if there are enough bacteria and microorganisms from other trophic levels for the plant’s stage of succession* (read about F:B ratio below).
  • Disease-causing fungi, yeasts, oomycetes. Lack of oxygen in compacted or waterlogged soils naturally selects against aerobic (beneficial) fungi and promotes growth of anaerobic pathogenic organisms. Read about the root causes of low oxygen in soils in the section above.

F:B ratio is the ratio between fungal and bacterial biomass in soil/compost. It is important because it defines the pH and the ratio between nitrate NO3- and ammonium NH4+ which correlates with plant succession. This means that plants from different stages of succession (weeds, veggies, grasses, shrubs, trees etc) require different nitrate-ammonium ratio and therefore different F:B ratio to thrive.  

Plant succession and F:B ratio

The most common issue is low F:B ratio for the plant’s stage of succession cause fungi is usually missing or present in very low amounts in agricultural fields. In some cases, if a field is left undisturbed, the succession moves from weeds towards later successional plants on its own. Unfortunately, it’s not always the case – very often abandoned fields stay in bacterial weedy stage for many years and the complete Soil Food Web should be restored in order to grow higher plants.

If F:B ratio is higher than needed for a plant, that can be because of a wrong crop rotation when earlier successional plants are planted after later successional plants.

*Even though there are maximum  levels of bacteria and fungi defined for each stage of succession, a plant can still thrive if biomass of bacteria or fungi or both exceed those values as long as F:B is right for the plant and enough predators are present. For example, for shrubs and vines (e.g. kiwi vines) the range for Bacteria is 135 – 1350 μg/g soil, 270 – 6750 μg/g soil for Fungi, and optimal F:B ratio is between 2 and 5. If bacterial biomass around your kiwi plant is 2000 μg/g (>1350 μg/g) and fungal biomass is 8000 μg/g (>6750 μg/g)) the F:B ratio is still in normal range for the plant and if predators are above minimum requirements that will result in higher productivity.

Predators. Micro-predators like protozoa and nematodes can be aerobic or anaerobic. Nematodes that are able to live in low oxygen conditions feed on plant roots (root-knot nematodes!). Anaerobic protozoa (ciliates) feed on bacteria and do not harm plants. Aerobic protozoa (flagellates, amoebae) and nematodes (bacteria-feeders, omnivores, fungal-feeders, predatory nematodes) are responsible for nutrient cycling in soil. They consume bacteria and fungi and release excessive nutrients in plant available forms (The Poop Loop!). Predators also help building soil structure by moving big aggregates around and creating larger and smaller pore spaces; stimulate and control prey groups (mostly bacteria and fungi, but also protozoa and nematodes).  Sometimes beneficial predators can protect plants from pests. For example, predatory nematodes that consume other nematodes usually go after root-feeding nematodes first! There are only minimum requirements for different functional groups of protozoa and nematodes for each stage of plant succession.

  • Low amount/absence of predators. As mentioned above, any kinds of soil disturbances such as unsustainable agricultural practices, natural disasters or climate change can destroy microorganisms, including micro-predators. Another factor is lack of food for certain functional groups. For example, soil lacking fungi will be lacking fungal-feeding nematodes and/or micro-arthropods
  • Anaerobic predators (too many) grow in reduced oxygen conditions that caused by compaction, waterlogging or excessive amount of nitrogen. For more details read the section “Anaerobic bacteria” above.

Micro-arthropods are also predators but we don’t assess them (just make notes) because there’s no sufficient scientific data about them. Most of micro-arthropods are beneficial – they release plant-available nutrients after consuming fungi, build soil structure and serve as taxicabs for bacteria, fungal spores, protozoa, protozoa cysts dispersing different species of microorganisms and increasing the diversity throughout the soil. However, there are species of Collembola and Symphylans that can start eating plant roots if there are not enough fungi in soil for them.

Diversity of bacteria and fungi species reflects the diversity of organic matter in soil (plants’ exudates, residues). Therefore monoculture and monocropping systems usually have low bacterial and fungal diversity. Protozoa and nematodes are often only able to feed on certain species of bacteria and fungi. Consequently, diversity of predators is defined by diversity of their preys.  

Seasonality and microbes’ levels. Levels of soil microorganisms naturally change throughout the season. For instance, when plants start producing fruit and seeds they put most of their energy into it and reduce the amount of root exudates significantly which results in reduction of bacterial and fungal populations and the rest of the Soil Food Web around roots. The F:B ratio varies with season as well. For example, in winter animals that feed on fungal hyphae go into hibernation and by the springtime snow-melt fungal biomass of the forest floor increases significantly, and so does the F:B ratio. A little later in the springtime those organisms wake up and start consuming fungi. As a result, by mid-August fungal biomass may decrease by thousand times (but keep in mind that healthy old-growth forests remain fungal dominatated at all times despite changes in fungal biomass).